Vitamin d supplement

The panel is split; natural sun is preferred over supplements for vitamin D.

Genuinely contested

For vitamin d optimization.

Sourced from the doctors, PhDs and clinicians behind Entrain. Updated

Both sides, in their own words

Our sources differ. Compare their views and the context behind each one.

One side

“I honestly do not recommend oral vitamin D... I'd rather they get outside in the sun the appropriate time of day at their latitude”

a board-certified cardiologist · source video · 00:07:00

The other

“Vitamin D supplementation masks true levels as per sun exposure and does not broadly improve health.”

a Princeton-trained molecular biology PhD · Instagram post

In their own words

One faithful sentence per source, linked to the moment it was said; quiet chips mark where money is involved.

a Princeton-trained molecular biology PhD against
“Vitamin D supplementation masks true levels as per sun exposure and does not broadly improve health.”

a Princeton-trained molecular biology PhD · Instagram post

a molecular biology PhD against
“Megadosing vitamin D depletes magnesium and shuts down natural vitamin D production, which is important for health.”

a molecular biology PhD · TikTok video

a GP with a Master of Public Health against
“Vitamin D has a J-shaped dose-response relationship where both deficiency and excess can reduce life expectancy; it acts as a seasonal adaptation hormone.”

a GP with a Master of Public Health · source video · 00:44:30

a nutritional sciences PhD conditional
“Lower 1,25 with elevated PTH suggests vitamin D deficiency requiring supplementation”

a nutritional sciences PhD · source video · 00:12:50

a licensed acupuncturist and clinician-educator recommend
“Vitamin D needs vary by ethnicity, body weight, health status, sun exposure, and co-actors; testing and retesting is crucial to optimize levels.”

a licensed acupuncturist and clinician-educator · source video · 00:04:00 sponsored

a performance scientist with a psychology PhD recommend
“Vitamin D production depends on sunlight and is important for physiological well-being during reduced daylight.”

a performance scientist with a psychology PhD · Instagram reel

Worth discussing with your GP, especially if you take medication or are pregnant. Entrain describes what is publicly taught; it does not prescribe.

Methylated b vitamins

Methylated B vitamins can be especially helpful for those with methylation pathway issues.

Strong consensus

“some people take methylated B vitamins to prevent a hangover ... something else which is very gentle and not going to cause any problems will be try methyl glycine or it's called TMG”

a molecular biology PhD · TikTok video

Grass-fed beef

Grass-fed beef offers better nutrition and supports soil and animal health.

Strong consensus

“grass-fed beef insane but how they do the research they take 100 head they put 50 on grain leave 50 on on grass when the ones on grain get fat they kill them all guess what the ones that grass are not as fat or lean”

a licensed acupuncturist and clinician-educator · source video · 00:14:32

Water filtration

Filtering water is a simple way to reduce exposure to unwanted substances.

Strong consensus

“water needs to be filtered and remember in order to filter toxins like that out of the water we must use a reverse osmosis or a distillation type filter”

a clinical nutritionist · source video · 00:06:00